Skip to main content

Committed Review


The Hotaches Committed series of films are now a raptly anticipated event in the climbing calendar year, and this new film, featuring five 'incredible climbing stories' is the best yet. The quality of production is superb and the film stories are future treasures of climbing documentary. They followed some high level traditional UK climbers throughout the year and the viewer is treated to an armchair sauna of the fear, trauma and elusive elation of high-end climbing.

The choice of stories is apt and varied. The first story begins with the thoughtful James Pearson attempting the 'last great problem' of The Groove at Cratcliffe Tor. This blank groove between two gritstone breaks was always deemed unclimbable but this did not deter James, he is filmed clutching a pebble the size of a peanut, rapt and intent... so this first film leads us gently into the microscopic obsession and invisible geometry of a climbing magician. The bizarre sequence of moves that James finally pulls out in a dangerous situation is a taster for what is to come in the movie.

Film 2, The Allrounder, follows the year of Dave MacLeod, who needs no introduction. The film captures the olympian levels of commitment and training that Dave must go through to operate at the highest level in each climbing discipline. It focuses on Dave's methodical and scientific breakdown approach, how he whittles a route's danger movement into a shape that is manageable for him both mentally and physically. Some of the footage is incredible indeed, especially the stomach churning insecurity of an attempt on the hard mixed climb of The Hurting, where Dave takes a sudden fall into the abyss and we are left wondering about the outcome until a rather relieved post-credits sequence! Dicing with death is an essential part of a climber's make-up and Dave explains how he travels the world preparing for portentous trad routes: training in Spain, repeating other hard routes with apparent ease, such as If 6 Was 9, a notorious Birkett route from the Lakes. This film is enlightening and shows the hard work and sacrifices of a climber attempting to maintain the highest levels in a largely unrecognised 'sporting' event.

Film 3 - Grit Kids - is the new generation of trad climbing, showing the natural and unfettered enthusiasm of youth on 'God's Own Rock' (grit). The 'kids' are the Whittaker siblings, whose flexibility and maturity on rock allows them to pull off some of the most incredible new grit ascents. Pete Whittaker turns his flexible mind and body to the contortionist's nightmare that is his own new route Dynamics of Change, a long-sought solution to the Braille Trail direct start. It was inspiring to see the kids approaching hard and dangerous extremes with an understanding rather than bravado and recklessness. Katy Whittaker's ascent of Kaluza Klein is just as eye-popping and thrilling!

Film 4 is a shorter one, following Steve McClure on his cool and quick repeat of Rhapsody at Dumbarton. This we may have seen before on E11, but the fall from the top moves is still a real gasper! Steve made this route look so doable and the moves so fluid, I went to the cupboard to get my sports ropes out. An inspiring sequence on the benefit of pure fitness in climbing, not to disrespect Steve's sheer talent on rock.

Film 5 is the highlight of the lot, returning to the remarkable James Perason and his 'silly obsession' (as he calls it) with the vertiginous blank wall of Hartland Point in Devon. This blank wall is unpegged by James ('given a facelift') and he attempts a clean ascent of the wall. The danger inherent in this route is superbly captured and its atmosphere of lonely leading above crashing waves is dark and very close to mortality. The fall he takes on this climb is simply terrifying and I could hardly watch as he returned to try and complete the route...

All in all, this is a an essential DVD for any climber's collection and one to return to when you are needing some inspiration for pushing your own limits! Well done to the Hotaches team, you can buy the DVD from their website HERE.

Popular posts from this blog

Vertical Landscapes: Exploring Glasgow's Hidden Bouldering

With the new guide to Glasgow Bouldering forthcoming, and with the last two years spent scouring our local landscapes for vertical diversion, many of us discovered a closer, more nuanced appreciation of climbing and how it helps maintain mental wellbeing as much as physical. The big mountains and wilderness landscapes were for the first time excluded from access and our pandemic taught us all to appreciate the landscapes on our doorstep. Even the urban world has its own small wildernesses and landscapes to immerse ourselves in for a while. For me, the daily walk in lockdown occasionally became a hunt for an esoteric piece of rock spied on the OS map or Google Earth. Rumours of boulders and mythologies of obscure rock were hunted down to help feed a hunger for the vertical. Even Dumbarton Rock was out of range, lying outside of the Glasgow City boundary. It's a venue which famously makes the blood run cold, with fiercely exposed overhanging routes, highball boulder problems and cl

The Lost Township of Grulin on Eigg

‘The Stony Place’ as it translates, the archaeological notes on the RCAHMS database for Eigg, state baldly the lost humanity of Grulin as early as an 1880 OS survey map: ‘…eighteen unroofed buildings, six enclosures and a field-system’. Now a scheduled monument and memorialised as a ‘depopulated settlement’, though it is not obvious if the verb is passive or aggressive, Grulin Uachdrach (Grulin Upper) is, like Hallaig on Raasay, a place of violent silence and resonance. Who lived here and why was the site abandoned? If it were not in Scotland, suspicions might fall to the climate, remoteness and apparent unsustainability of the stony place, a rabble of large rocks under the steep slopes of An Sgurr, but the carefully constructed walls tell us it was once a thriving township – the kilns, folds and blackhouse walls integrated with the giant boulders such as Clach Hosdail. In 1853 the whole of the village of Grulin, both upper and lower, housed fourteen families who were forced to l

Timeline Walks of Scotland #Hallaig to Screapadal on Raasay

'Tha tìm, am fiadh, an coille Hallaig ...' Hallaig - the lost village of Raasay - is a powerful place. Arguably, it has become a shibboleth for the soul of Gaelic culture. To visit it, to just be there momentarily and feel the resonance of the place, is to know the fragility of place and home, of how kinship can be shattered and how loss can invade a land. Aptly, Hallaig is now a site of pilgrimage for those who value the universal lessons of history.  There are t errible reasons for the loss of Hallaig. Its silent mouths of abandoned shielings, the dumb sheep meandering amongst the ruins, whisper with Sorley MacLean's poetry. The place misses the sounds of day-to-day community, and all around the woods and burns and slopes this tough but rich landscape once made this a hardy paradise under the eastern cliffs of Raasay. Facing east to the dawn and overlooking the peninsula of Applecross and the berry-dark depths of the Inner Sound, the walk to Hallaig leads quietly